Social Justice

Almost everyday we read or hear about an injustice taking place in the world somewhere. These events may be localized in which case they seem to hit home to people we know or they may be more global, occurring to people we do not know in a remote region from our normal existence. In most cases, however, the social injustice relates whether abstractly or personally to something from our life or at least a connection to something close to us. Injustice by its very meaning is an example of an event that is not fair. While I may spend some time discussing the impossibility of fairness in all situations, I do think that a continued effort to be fair is a worthy objective for all of us. I suppose fair does not mean equal but it does mean allowing for equal opportunity or in some cases equivalent punishment for like infractions.

When one person's freedom is another person's straitjacket, it is not true freedom. If one hits another on the head and takes the person's money, then the crime should be punished. If my right to own a dog infringes on my neighbor's right to freedom from a barking dog, then my dog needs to stop barking or go away. Social justice allows for fair treatment for all and the right to liberty and the pursuit of happiness. When my pursuit prevents the happiness of someone else, then I lose my right to the pursuit. Otherwise I am free to pursue happiness in all its myriad forms. But criminal activity aside, it is those ambiguous situations that do not seem right but are not infractions of the law where we need to act in a manner that allows for fair treatment for all.

When I look back on history and think through the 40 Acres and Mule program from the Reconstruction, I find myself feeling ill at the mistreatment of the former slaves. The program was well intentioned, as most programs area, but the reality was challenging only to be followed by a rescinding of the idea. "Here is a gift to help you in the future...oh never mind." No justice there. In Brownsville, Texas in 1906 an unidentified shooting by two or three people led to the dishonorable discharge of an entire unit--167 soldiers. These men who had spent their lives fighting for the United States lost their jobs, their pensions, and any medical benefits for their families. They were left destitute and disgraced and were entirely innocent.

These examples are obviously dramatic and tend to incite our emotions quickly when examined. But how many times do we witness social injustice on simpler but no less egregious situations? Lost jobs without reason, kickbacks for contracted work, mistreatment of those different from us, public funds spent for personal gain, unwarranted punishments, misappropriations, insider trading, discrimination, and the list goes on and on. While I am not a supporter of excessive legislation and enjoy living in my "people want to do the right thing" world, I do think we should continue to exercise fairness and equal treatment for all. Randian philosophies aside, we owe it to each other and to all people to create a society that allows for equality and prevents liberty at the exclusion of other people' freedom.